Continued Social Work Phone: 866-419-0818


How Does Human Trafficking Differ From Other Crimes?

Sophie Nathenson, PhD

December 1, 2025

Question

How does human trafficking differ from other crimes?

Answer

Psychological control is a defining feature of human trafficking, setting it apart from crimes such as smuggling and kidnapping. While smuggling typically involves consensual border crossing and kidnapping often centers on physical force for a one-time gain, human trafficking is characterized by ongoing exploitation, often for labor or commercial sex. Traffickers frequently use psychological tactics such as manipulation, false promises, and threats against victims or their loved ones to maintain control. This form of coercion can be more powerful than physical violence, as it paralyzes victims and prevents them from seeking help, even when physical escape is possible. Unlike the visible signs of abuse in other crimes, the effects of psychological control in trafficking are often hidden, making detection and intervention more challenging.

 

This Ask the Expert is an edited excerpt from the course, 'Protecting Vulnerable Populations: Human Trafficking Identification for Health Professionals, presented by Sophie Nathenson, PhD. 

Continued and its subsidiaries provide professional education authored by qualified Subject Matter Experts for continuing education purposes. These materials are intended for educational purposes and do not constitute medical advice or a substitute for individual clinical judgment. Continued is not a clinical healthcare provider; the licensed professional is solely responsible for ensuring that the application of any techniques or information presented is within their legal scope of practice and jurisdictional requirements.


sophie nathenson

Sophie Nathenson, PhD

Sophie Nathenson is a Medical Sociologist, professor, and consultant based in Portland, Oregon. She is the founder and Director of the Bachelor's of Science in Population Health Management program and faculty in the Masters of Science in Allied Health program at Oregon Tech. She is also the owner of Widespread Wellness Consulting, providing career mentorship and education for individuals and groups working on promoting social, physical, emotional, and mental wellbeing. 


Related Courses

Protecting Vulnerable Populations: Human Trafficking Identification for Health Professionals
Presented by Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Video

Presenter

Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Course: #2508Level: Introductory1 Hour
  'Detailed information about the sociological perspective, red flags and resources'   Read Reviews
This course equips behavioral health clinicians with the knowledge and skills necessary to identify and support victims of human trafficking, in compliance with Michigan's Administrative Rule 338.2929. Participants will explore the various types and venues of human trafficking in the United States, learn to recognize warning signs in healthcare settings for both adults and minors, and become familiar with resources for reporting suspected cases.

HIV in Sociological Perspective: Evidence-Based Care, Stigma, and Intervention
Presented by Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Video

Presenter

Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Course: #2788Level: Intermediate2 Hours
  'Super informative and covered a lot of parts of care of HIV'   Read Reviews
This course introduces the sociological factors in HIV prevalence and treatment, including stigma, structural inequality, and political influences on care. Participants will learn how these factors shape mental health outcomes and engagement in care, with a discussion on trauma-informed, culturally responsive, and evidence-based interventions to support individuals living with or at risk for HIV.

Trauma & Suicide Risk in Veteran Populations
Presented by Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Video

Presenter

Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Course: #2281Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'post traumatic growth'   Read Reviews
This course provides an overview of the well-being of Veterans in America, including physical and mental health. The role of trauma is discussed in relation to mental health outcomes such as suicide and increased risk of adverse social determinants of health. Aspects of trauma-informed care that address the unique needs of the Veteran population are presented as they relate to individual and societal-level interventions.

Into Action: Program Design to Address Social Determinants of Mental Health
Presented by Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Video

Presenter

Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Course: #2314Level: Advanced1 Hour
  'Course was informative for the helping process'   Read Reviews
In this course, participants will get an overview of the social determinants of mental health in America, and an introduction to designing initiatives or programs to address such determinants. Best practices in working across sectors, community engagement, and evaluation will be discussed.

Structural Violence: Systemic Inequality and Substance Abuse Prevention
Presented by Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Live WebinarThu, Sep 3, 2026 at 3:00 pm EDT
Thu, Sep 3, 2026 at 3:00 pm EDT

Presenter

Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Course: #2830Level: Intermediate1 Hour
This course invites mental health professionals to move beyond person-centered interventions and examine how policies, institutions, and social systems create both risk and opportunity. Participants will explore how structural forces influence substance use, ethical implications for treatment, and strategies for integrating a structural lens into clinical practice. This course was designed for an interprofessional audience.