Continued Respiratory Therapy Phone: 866-382-0799


How Some Medical Interventions Be Deemed Futile?

Shawna Strickland, PhD, CAE, RRT, RRT-NPS, RRT-ACCS, AE-C, FAARC

March 15, 2023

Share:

Question

Why provide interventions deemed futile?

Answer

The thought of taking away something that could help a family member live is extraordinarily challenging. The study that Jox et al. (2012) completed asked those folks why we would provide these interventions. The reasons that we do such things are primarily emotional. Guilt, grief, fear of the legal system, and concerns about the family's reactions. They are providing an opportunity for the family to come to terms with the end of life. It may take a few days or a week for those folks to come to terms and understand that this might be the best thing to do—also some institutional barriers. There could be a delay for several reasons, establishing a serious prognosis. In some states, the courts allow the hospital to discontinue futile medical intervention after a specific time. They wait for that time to expire, go through the court system, and have families visit the patient before the patient passes away. In this study by Cifrese et al., 2018, the authors conclude that managing futility could be improved through communication training, knowledge transfer, organizational improvements, and emotional and ethical support systems. 

Jox et al. (2012) study provided a treatment algorithm based on the results of their study. Number one, asking about the patient's preferred goal of treatment. In some situations, this might be a challenging conversation because perhaps this was an unexpected event. There was no time to talk with the patient about this. In that case, you must rely on the patient's family or surrogate decision-makers. Perhaps this is a stage four COPD patient who has been in the hospital many times. This happens to be the last of those admissions—but understanding the patient's preferred goal of treatment is important. Patient preferred goal, what would you like to receive? What is your goal from this admission? Are you trying to get back to a higher quality of life? Are you trying to get home so you can pass away at home? What is your goal here?

Then we must identify whether we can realistically achieve these goals. If they cannot, if this patient is on a mechanical ventilator, their pupils are dilated and non-reactive, the patient's family says, "I want my patient to get up, walk out the door, go home, have a steak dinner," there is a strong likelihood that that is not going to happen. As factual judgment, now we have to say, "Okay, this is not a reasonable expectation of the outcome of this patient's disease process." If it is realistic, does the benefit of that goal outweigh the risks and burdens? Yes, we can institute mechanical ventilation, but we all have to remember that mechanical ventilation is not a benign intervention. If it is, if the mechanical ventilator is mismanaged, then we can cause structural damage. We can cause barotrauma and volutrauma. We can cause all kinds of fun issues that we would prefer our patients not to experience. It is not a foregone conclusion that the patient will rest on mechanical ventilation to become extubated. There will be no consequences. Again, can the benefits outweigh the risks and burdens? If not, we are back to that pathway of identifying an alternative goal of treatment. 

This Ask the Expert is an edited excerpt from the course, Futile or Fruitful: Medical Interventions and the Respiratory Therapist, presented by Shawna Strickland, Ph.D., CAE, RRT, RRT-NPS, RRT-ACCS, AE-C, FAARC.


shawna strickland

Shawna Strickland, PhD, CAE, RRT, RRT-NPS, RRT-ACCS, AE-C, FAARC

Dr. Strickland is a registered respiratory therapist and association executive. After over a decade in clinical care, she transitioned into higher education, serving as faculty and in program administration at Southern Illinois University – Carbondale and the University of Missouri in Columbia. In 2010, she served as a clinical ethics consultant at the University of Missouri Center for Health Ethics. She transitioned into association management in 2013 at the American Association for Respiratory Care as the Associate Executive Director of Education, which expanded to include member services. She is the Associate Executive Director of Programs at the American Epilepsy Society, leading the clinical activities, research, and education divisions. In addition to association management, Dr. Strickland serves as adjunct faculty at Rush University, teaching doctoral courses in educational leadership in the College of Health Sciences. She has a special interest in clinical practice guidelines. She is a panelist on the Society for Critical Care Medicine End-of-Life Care in the Adult ICU guideline currently in development.

In March 2021, she transitioned to the American Epilepsy Society to continue focusing on effective association practice, clinical activities, research, and quality continuing education. In addition to association management, Dr. Strickland serves as adjunct faculty at Rush University, teaching doctoral courses in educational leadership in the College of Health Sciences. Her research interests include online and distance education, self-directed learning, evidence-based guidelines, healthcare workforce shortages, palliative and end-of-life care, moral distress in healthcare providers, and alarm safety.


Related Courses

Futile or Fruitful: Medical Interventions and the Respiratory Therapist
Presented by Shawna Strickland, PhD, CAE, RRT, RRT-NPS, RRT-ACCS, AE-C, FAARC
Video

Presenter

Shawna Strickland, PhD, CAE, RRT, RRT-NPS, RRT-ACCS, AE-C, FAARC
Course: #1573Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'validation of such conditions in the workplace, identifying burnout and changing workplace if necessary,'   Read Reviews
Interventions that are not likely to produce a medical benefit for the patient are referred to as futile. In this presentation, futility is defined, and the limitations of practical use are identified. Case studies that illustrate the concept of futility and the challenges associated with the application are presented.

The Use of Noninvasive Ventilation at the End of Life
Presented by Shawna Strickland, PhD, CAE, RRT, RRT-NPS, RRT-ACCS, AE-C, FAARC
Video

Presenter

Shawna Strickland, PhD, CAE, RRT, RRT-NPS, RRT-ACCS, AE-C, FAARC
Course: #1434Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'I am seeing more end of life palliative care patients at my hospital'   Read Reviews
Noninvasive ventilation is a common modality provided in acute, long-term, and home care environments to provide respiratory support to patients with a variety of acute and chronic disease pathologies. Though NIV is used predominantly as a bridge to recovery in acute disease pathologies and as ongoing support in chronic disease pathologies, some clinicians advocate for the use of NIV for comfort measures at the end of life. This intermediate course provides a basis for the analysis of ethical dilemmas and debates the ethical arguments for and against the use of NIV at the end of life.

Palliative Care and the Respiratory Therapist
Presented by Shawna Strickland, PhD, CAE, RRT, RRT-NPS, RRT-ACCS, AE-C, FAARC
Video

Presenter

Shawna Strickland, PhD, CAE, RRT, RRT-NPS, RRT-ACCS, AE-C, FAARC
Course: #1969Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'Very educational'   Read Reviews
This course explores the ethical considerations and the fundamental distinctions between palliative care and hospice, providing respiratory therapists with a comprehensive understanding of these approaches to patient care. Additionally, it delves into the application of palliative care principles within the context of chronic lung disease while also emphasizing the crucial role that respiratory therapists play in delivering compassionate and holistic palliative care to patients.

Ethical Considerations in Post-Acute Care: A Clinical Perspective
Presented by Kathleen Weissberg, OTD, OTR/L, CMDCP, CDP
Video

Presenter

Kathleen Weissberg, OTD, OTR/L, CMDCP, CDP
Course: #1565Level: Intermediate2 Hours
  'Instructor presented the material very nicely'   Read Reviews
In this session, practical information about ethics is provided from a clinical perspective. Core ethical principles as they relate to healthcare and senior care are reviewed. Behaviors that are considered unethical by most credentialing bodies are considered as well as legal and ethical issues typically encountered in one’s daily profession. The course applies models for analyzing and resolving ethical dilemmas in healthcare including CELIBATE, RIPS, and the Rest Four Component Model. Case examples illustrating various ethical dilemmas and issues that can take place in senior care settings are offered to enhance learning.

Ethics in Healthcare
Presented by Lori Taylor, PhD, RRT
Text

Presenter

Lori Taylor, PhD, RRT
Course: #1092Level: Introductory1 Hour
  'Asy to understand'   Read Reviews
This course will review and discuss the ethical and legal responsibility of the healthcare provider. The course will discuss ethical principles and the code of conduct for Respiratory Therapists.

Our site uses cookies to improve your experience. By using our site, you agree to our Privacy Policy.