Continued Counseling Phone: 866-970-4840


How Does Human Trafficking Differ From Other Crimes?

Sophie Nathenson, PhD

December 1, 2025

Share:

Question

How does human trafficking differ from other crimes?

Answer

Psychological control is a defining feature of human trafficking, setting it apart from crimes such as smuggling and kidnapping. While smuggling typically involves consensual border crossing and kidnapping often centers on physical force for a one-time gain, human trafficking is characterized by ongoing exploitation, often for labor or commercial sex. Traffickers frequently use psychological tactics such as manipulation, false promises, and threats against victims or their loved ones to maintain control. This form of coercion can be more powerful than physical violence, as it paralyzes victims and prevents them from seeking help, even when physical escape is possible. Unlike the visible signs of abuse in other crimes, the effects of psychological control in trafficking are often hidden, making detection and intervention more challenging.

 

This Ask the Expert is an edited excerpt from the course, 'Protecting Vulnerable Populations: Human Trafficking Identification for Health Professionals, presented by Sophie Nathenson, PhD. 


sophie nathenson

Sophie Nathenson, PhD

Sophie Nathenson is a Medical Sociologist, professor, and consultant based in Portland, Oregon. She is the founder and Director of the Bachelor's of Science in Population Health Management program and faculty in the Masters of Science in Allied Health program at Oregon Tech. She is also the owner of Widespread Wellness Consulting, providing career mentorship and education for individuals and groups working on promoting social, physical, emotional, and mental wellbeing. 


Related Courses

Protecting Vulnerable Populations: Human Trafficking Identification for Health Professionals
Presented by Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Video

Presenter

Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Course: #2159Level: Introductory1 Hour
  'interesting topic'   Read Reviews
This course equips behavioral health clinicians with the knowledge and skills necessary to identify and support victims of human trafficking, in compliance with Michigan's Administrative Rule 338.2929. Participants will explore the various types and venues of human trafficking in the United States, learn to recognize warning signs in healthcare settings for both adults and minors, and become familiar with resources for reporting suspected cases.

Trauma & Suicide Risk in Veteran Populations
Presented by Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Video

Presenter

Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Course: #1978Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'research data presented was well done'   Read Reviews
This course provides an overview of the well-being of Veterans in America, including physical and mental health. The role of trauma is discussed in relation to mental health outcomes such as suicide and increased risk of adverse social determinants of health. Aspects of trauma-informed care that address the unique needs of the Veteran population are presented as they relate to individual and societal-level interventions.

American Society, Culture, and Mental Health
Presented by Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Video

Presenter

Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Course: #1801Level: Introductory1 Hour
  'There was a lot of information that has practical application with Mental Health Counseling'   Read Reviews
In this course, central paradigms of Western societies will be explored in relation to their impact on social, emotional, and mental health. The influence of Western culture on medical models is discussed, including its impact on shaping how mental illness is viewed and addressed in society.

Interdisciplinary and Non-Pharmacological Approaches to Pain Management
Presented by Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Video

Presenter

Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Course: #1825Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'Very good overview of a variety of non-pharmacological approaches'   Read Reviews
This course provides an overview of pain in America and the impact of Opioids, addiction, and drug poisoning. Evidenced-based, non-pharmacological approaches to pain management are discussed within a framework of interdisciplinary and integrative care. This course meets New Jersey compliance and addresses the risks and signs of opioid abuse, addiction, and diversion.

Racism and Mental Health
Presented by Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Video

Presenter

Sophie Nathenson, PhD
Course: #1587Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'cultural recognition with racism'   Read Reviews
This course reviews disparities in mental health outcomes by race, focusing on race as a social construction and a social determinant of health. Research is presented on the impact of racism on mental health, occurring at interpersonal, cultural, and institutional levels. Clinical and policy-level recommendations are discussed that have the potential to address the detrimental effects of discrimination on mental health.

Our site uses cookies to improve your experience. By using our site, you agree to our Privacy Policy.