What Legal Risks Should Clinicians Consider Before Relying on AI Tools in Telehealth Practice?
Question
What legal risks should clinicians consider before relying on AI tools in telehealth practice?
Answer
No AI vendor agreement currently guarantees the accuracy of the information the tool produces, even when marketing materials describe its capabilities favorably. This gap matters because the legal liability for any resulting error, incomplete information, or overly broad clinical statement falls on the clinician and their license, not on the AI vendor or the end user who happened to rely on the output. This risk extends to compliance work as well: using AI to draft telehealth policies or to research whether a particular legal requirement is in effect is unreliable, since AI models can generate outdated or simply incorrect information, and much of the detailed regulatory information clinicians need is not accessible to these tools in the first place.
A related concern involves AI-driven clinical flagging systems, such as tools that automatically flag any indication of depressive symptoms as a suicide risk. Over-flagging can create a "boy who cried wolf" problem that generates excessive documentation and dilutes attention to genuine risk, so any decision to disable such a flag should be restricted to the lead practitioner rather than administrative staff, and should be based on the clinician's own training and judgment rather than deferred to the software. The consistent theme is that just because AI can perform a task does not mean it should be trusted to do so without direct clinical oversight and independent verification.

Annemarie Kelly
JD, LLM
Related Courses
Ethical and Practical Impacts of AI in Behavioral Health and Interdisciplinary Settings
This course offers an in-depth exploration of how AI is shaping behavioral health and interdisciplinary care. This course explores the latest AI technologies, their real-world applications, ethical considerations, and how they can enhance patient outcomes. From predictive analytics to AI-driven therapeutic tools, this course will equip you with the knowledge to harness the power of AI while addressing critical ethical considerations. This course additionally explores considerations of telehealth when clinicians utilize AI.A Risk Management Approach to Ethics in Clinical Practice
This presentation offers a risk management approach to addressing ethical issues in clinical mental health practice. Rather than focusing solely on avoiding lawsuits or licensing complaints, the presentation emphasizes ethically sound, client-centered decision-making that protects client wellbeing, respects client rights, and supports compliance with relevant ethical standards, laws, and agency policies. Participants will explore strategies for identifying, assessing, and responding to practice risks, particularly when clinicians face competing interests, conflicting obligations, or uncertainty about the best course of action. This course was developed for an interprofessional audience.Ethical Integrity in Mental Health: A Framework for Proactive Decision-Making
This course emphasizes the use of structured ethical decision-making models to reduce ambiguity and strengthen clinical judgment. Participants will explore strategies for preventing ethical errors, applying a comprehensive decision-making framework, understanding the interplay between legal and ethical considerations, and effectively managing threats to confidentiality. The training highlights practical, clinically relevant applications across individual, family, couples, and group therapy contexts. Clinicians will leave with enhanced tools for navigating complex ethical challenges in diverse treatment settings. This course was designed for an interprofessional audience.